Chicken Noodles

Here is our easy, must-try ultimate comfort food recipe, Chicken Noodles. Cozy, tender egg noodles and chicken in a thick, rich broth served over a large helping of the creamiest mashed potatoes is super easy to prepare with just a handful of basic ingredients.

This classic meal is also known in the Midwest as Amish chicken noodles. Growing up this was without a doubt one of my favorite childhood meals. And since beginning to eat gluten and dairy free over 13 years ago, this was one of the meals I missed the most.

I mean have you ever tried egg noodles before? They are incredibly delicious and tender– just so good!

Thankfully, recently we discovered gluten free and dairy free egg noodles perfect for this recipe {keep scrolling for a direct link to learn more about these tender noodles}.

And this isn’t a “soup” recipe. Instead this is a hearty, comforting dish of noodles and chicken in a thick sauce served over a side of mashed potatoes.

Growing up in an Amish community with Amish babysitters, friends, classmates, and family, this recipe was frequently enjoyed by all… handing plates of this across the dinner table to each other. And my mom always had to prepare enough for seconds and leftovers. Plus this was and still is commonly found on the menu in local restaurants.

Keep scrolling for our recipe ingredients list. You will be excited to know this recipe only calls for a handful of easy to grab ingredients.

chicken noodle ingredients

• creamy mashed potatoes— we absolutely love our go-to mashed potato recipe. We use a secret ingredient that makes them ultra creamy and buttery every single time. Or use your favorite homemade recipe.
• chicken broth or stock— we prefer the Pacific brand
• shredded chicken— if you want to make this recipe as easy as possible, use canned Valley Fresh Organic Chicken. Here is their allergen statement. Baked, slow cooked, and rotisserie chicken also have wonderful flavor and can be used.
• gluten free dried egg noodles— we use the Jovial brand gluten free egg tagliatelle. This brand is gluten free, dairy free, soy free, peanut and tree nut free.
• kosher salt
• ground pepper
• optional— you can also substitute shredded beef and beef stock for chicken

kitchen utensils

• 2 large stock pots
• large strainer— for the mashed potatoes
• handheld mixer or stand mixer— to cream the mashed potatoes

frequently asked questions

what gluten free egg noodles work with this recipe

At this time we’ve only found these egg tagliatelle noodles by the Jovial brand in the US. We purchase them at Walmart, our local health food store, and online at Amazon.

can beef be substituted for the chicken

Yes, shredded canned beef with beef broth also tastes absolutely delicious in this recipe. For the shredded beef substitute, you can also use slow cooker shredded beef or canned beef. And gluten and dairy free free broth.

how is this served

We make a bed of mashed potatoes in a bowl and then use tongs to transfer the long egg noodles onto the plate. Lastly with a ladle with scoop out the thick sauce and shredded chicken. Then top with salt and pepper to taste.

can this recipe be made ahead of time

While this gluten free and dairy free dinner recipe is best served the day it is made, you can also make it a day or two in advance. Here are our tips– prepare the creamy mashed potatoes as directed, and after they have completely cooled, transfer to an airtight container and refrigerate. We suggest rewhipping the potatoes when you reheat them to serve.

To prepare the chicken noodle mixture, we suggest preparing the mixture as directed, allowing to cool completely, and refrigerating until ready to serve. Reheat just before serving.

more easy dinner recipes

• shepherd’s pie— seasoned ground beef, tender carrots and celery, and topped with a fluffy layer of creamy mashed potatoes
• slow cooker taco soup— packed with vegetables and protein, this tastes fresh and it’s filling. And the heat from the fire-roasted tomatoes gives this soup a bit of heat.
• teriyaki chicken— grilled teriyaki marinated chicken with pineapple rings and mini sweet peppers over a warm bed of jasmine rice, served with a sprinkle of sesame seeds and fresh cilantro
• spaghetti pie— loaded with a layer of hearty meat sauce over creamy and buttery ricotta spaghetti noodles garnished with fresh chopped herbs and dairy free cheese for an easy dinner recipe the whole family will enjoy

3 dessert recipes to try

Whether you are new to eating gluten and dairy free or a seasoned veteran, here are few must-try recipes– fudgy brownies, chewy chocolate chip cookies, and nutter butter cookies.

You will also find several delicious and easy sweet, quick bread recipes on our website.

our cookbook

Did you know we have an eBook, The Classics, available for instant download? You will receive 16 of our reader favorite recipes at your fingertips– including our delicious yeast free cinnamon rolls with cream cheese frosting and chocolate cream pie.

This is a wonderful gift to share with a loved one who is gluten free and dairy free too.

lastly

Chicken Noodles served over warm, buttery mashed potatoes is not only the ultimate comfort meal, but it is also the perfect go-to for chilly winter nights.

And you will fall in love with these tender egg noodles and sauce sprinkled with salt and pepper. This recipe smells amazing as it simmers on the stove top, and it tastes even better. Plus it is ready in just minutes when you prepare the mashed potatoes while the chicken noodles come together.

You will find more gluten free and dairy free recipes on our website, Eating Gluten and Dairy Free.

Follow along on our Facebook, Pinterest, and Instagram. We share product alerts, gluten and dairy free living tips, new recipes, food travel hacks, and brand giveaways.

We don’t want you to miss the absolute best of eating gluten and dairy free.

Eat well and feel well,

Jill

Keep scrolling to sign up for our exclusive emails below.

Share for others and save for later!