Homemade Oreo Milkshake

Thick and smooth, this delicious homemade Oreo Milkshake combines the best of both the chocolate cookies and vanilla dairy free ice cream to craft the perfect homemade milkshake with chocolate sauce.

Not too long ago I realized I'd committed a serious mom fail. Quite honestly it stopped me in my tracks as I thought to myself, "How did this happen?"

You see while my family was visiting extended family in Salt Lake City. One evening we were feasting on burgers at a local burger shop.

That's when my kids noticed one of our relatives enjoying a creamy milkshake with her meal. As in, stop the train -- my kids just stared looking dumbfounded at this goodness in a cup.

They even asked her what she'd ordered and then it dawned on me. My kids had never seen a milkshake, let alone tasted one.

I couldn't believe my daughter was 10 and never enjoyed a thick and creamy milkshake. It was in that moment I knew what I needed to do.

To put it another way, within a week I had purchased this milkshake maker from Amazon and was perfecting my recipes.

Of course, there were no qualms from the kids as they enjoyed every moment as official milkshake taste testers. Would it be any surprise then that my homemade oreo milkshake recipe quickly became one of our favorites?

This homemade oreo milkshake recipe is not only straight forward, but you'll also find this recipe to be creamy and thick every time!

Homemade Oreo Milkshake Ingredient Notes

• dairy free ice cream --2 certified GF and vegan brands are So Delicious and Nada Moo!
• dairy free milk -- we always have unsweetened almond milk on hand for such occasions, however use your favorite dairy free milk
• oreo sandwich cookies -- gluten and dairy free brands include Glutino and Kinnikinnick KinniTOOS chocolate cream sandwich cookies. Keep in mind Glutino does manufacture their "oreo" cookies with other dairy products and doesn't clarify their manufacturing process in regards to dairy, while KinniTOOS is a very allergen free friendly brand. You will find their long list of "free from's" on their website along with their manufacturing processes here. If you are sensitive dairy cross contamination, I would suggest the KinniTOOS brand.
• vanilla extract
• optional toppings: dairy free chocolate syrup, dairy free whipped topping like So Delicious Coco Whip, maraschino cherries or sprinkles.
• milkshake maker or a blender -- we purchased this retro, drugstore soda fountain style milkshake maker

How to Make a Homemade Oreo Milkshake

1. Add the dairy free milk, dairy free ice cream, vanilla extract, and crushed Oreo cookies to a blender or milkshake canister.
2. If using a milkshake canister, briefly mash the mixture with a fork first, then blend in the milkshake maker until smooth.
3. Blend until the milkshake reaches the thickness you like best.
4. Pour into 2 glasses and top with extra crushed Oreo crumbs, dairy free whipped topping, chocolate syrup, and a cherry.

Recipe Tips & Variations

• For an extra-thick milkshake, use slightly softened ice cream and fewer ice cubes if your blender needs them.
• Swap in chocolate dairy free ice cream for an even richer, more chocolatey milkshake.
• No milkshake maker? A regular blender works just as well – just pulse until you reach your desired consistency.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this milkshake ahead of time?

Milkshakes are best blended fresh and served right away, since they'll start to melt and separate the longer they sit. You can crush the Oreo cookies and measure out your other ingredients ahead of time to make blending quicker.

What should I serve with this milkshake?

This milkshake makes a fun treat on its own, or pair it with a plate of cookies for dunking for an extra special dessert.

What else can I add to this milkshake?

Try adding a scoop of peanut butter, a handful of chocolate chips, or swapping in mint chocolate chip ice cream for a fun twist.

How do I store leftovers?

Milkshakes don't store well once blended, but you can freeze any leftover portions in an airtight container for up to a week and re-blend before serving.

more delicious treats

• walnut brownie sundae skillet -- just grab spoons and dig into this warm brownie topped with nuts and ice cream
• oreo ice cream cake -- yes, here's your 100% gluten and dairy free seven layer ice cream cake
• the ultimate peanut butter brownies -- perfect for any occasion. This chocolate and peanut butter combo is phenomenal. You'd never guess it's gluten and dairy free.

lastly

It may be winter time in Montana, the last place you'd expect a family to be enjoying every drop of their thick and creamy homemade oreo milkshakes. But we are -- we're definitely living the gluten and dairy free life now.

Mark my words this will be one of my go-to recipes this summer! Nothing will cool us off faster than this homemade oreo milkshake treat.

And did I mention you'll find more recipe ideas for every occasion on my website? If you're new to my website, grab yourself a cup of joe and start pinning here. You'll want to follow me on Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest too. New gluten and dairy free pins are added to my Pinterest boards weekly.

Let me know in the comments if you found this recipe enjoyable. Thank you and enjoy.

Eat well and feel well,

Share for others and save for later!